United Kingdom · Payroll handover
Starter checklist: multiple student loans and a postgraduate loan
Keep declaration A, B or C separate from loan setup. Check the official route when a new employee reports more than one student-loan plan.
Direct answer
Does reporting two student-loan plans mean deducting both at once?
GOV.UK says only one student-loan plan type can be deducted at a time, while a postgraduate loan can run alongside it. Where several plans are reported and you do not know which is in repayment, the official guidance uses the lowest recovery threshold until an SL1 arrives. This is a separate decision from starter declaration A, B or C.
Source checked 2026-10-19: HMRC employer help card: completed C versus incomplete checklist. GOV.UK: student and postgraduate loan checks for a new employee.
Record the uncertainty before selecting the payroll route
| Information received | Question to resolve | Separate record |
|---|---|---|
| Student loan exists; no plan identified | Use the current unknown-plan instructions; GOV.UK currently specifies Plan 5 pending SL1. | Do not treat a blank plan as no loan. |
| Several plans reported; repayment plan unclear | Follow the multiple-plan guidance and current recovery thresholds. | Do not activate two student-loan deductions. |
| Student and postgraduate loan reported | Check both categories under the applicable instructions. | A postgraduate loan is not a second student-plan type. |
| SL1 or other HMRC notice arrives | Follow the notice and applicable payroll instructions. | Keep received date and change history. |
Invented handover: an employee selects declaration B, reports two student-loan plans and confirms a postgraduate loan. A note saying only “three loans” does not tell payroll which student plan is in repayment. Keep the declaration answer, each reported plan, the uncertainty and the postgraduate answer in separate fields. Apply the current official route; do not change declaration B to C to compensate for missing loan information. No threshold amounts or deduction estimates are supplied here because the payroll period and current plan rules must be checked. If information changes after the first FPS, keep the earlier submission event and use the appropriate update instructions.
Checklist controls
- Record the starter declaration separately from loan answers.
- Distinguish no plan identified from multiple reported plans.
- Check current thresholds and the applicable HMRC instructions.
- Keep postgraduate information and later notices visible.
Original handover log: evidence before a payroll change
| Event | Record privately | Open question |
|---|---|---|
| Employee provides answers | Form version, received date, declaration and missing information | Is there a usable P45 or a starter-information route? |
| Payroll prepares first run | Declaration, tax code, basis and source used | Does each setting follow the applicable HMRC instructions? |
| First FPS submitted | Submission date and payroll acknowledgement/reference | A saved draft or completed checklist is not this event. |
| Information arrives afterwards | Document type, received date and earlier FPS status | Is this a late P45, an HMRC notice or other new information? Follow that update route. |
Invented sequence: a checklist arrives on 6 October; payroll sends the first FPS on 9 October; a P45 arrives on 12 October. Label the P45 as received after the first FPS instead of silently replacing the original checklist record. Keep the original decision and the later action with their dates, so a reviewer can reconstruct what payroll knew at each stage. A different case in which no FPS was submitted by 12 October has a different history even though the same two documents exist. Do not select a declaration to target a preferred take-home amount. This page stores no employee information and does not determine a personalised correction.
Decision first, recorded payroll treatment second
| Information available | Route to check |
|---|---|
| Completed answers: another current job or pension received | C branch; the help card specifies BR. |
| No current other job or pension; earlier job or listed taxable benefits since 6 April | B branch; checklist specifies Week 1/Month 1 treatment. |
| None of those circumstances | A branch; follow the checklist’s cumulative treatment. |
| No P45 and checklist cannot be completed | HMRC help card: C and 0T; use the official tool for payroll details. |
Handover example: a note saying only «C» is ambiguous. Record privately whether it came from completed employee answers or unavailable information, plus the source used to establish the tax code. A payroll reviewer should be able to distinguish these two histories without guessing. This site provides no form for names, National Insurance numbers or payslips.
HMRC starter checklist: current form and instructions.
Frequently asked questions
Is an unidentified single plan the same as several known plans with unclear repayment?
No. The current GOV.UK page gives different instructions for those situations: Plan 5 pending SL1 when the employee cannot identify the plan, and the lowest recovery threshold where multiple plans are reported but repayment is unclear. Check the current official page and any HMRC notice before processing; do not collapse both cases into a generic default.
Independent payroll guide, not a personalised tax-code ruling. Later HMRC notices, P45 handling and special cases require the applicable instructions. The 0T basis must be checked in the official payroll route; a declaration letter alone is insufficient.
Compare pension payments, contributions and benefits · Handle a P45 received after first pay